An analysis of genocide as the extermination of native americans

To do so, it adopted a policy, formally institutionalized through the Indian Removal Act ofof moving all Indians living east of the Mississippi River to Indian Territory the modern states of Kansas and Oklahoma.

America has many positive aspects. Fulcrum,77— However, these differences show remarkable similarity with the controversy surrounding the Holocaust deniers who do not deny that Holocaust occurred, but try to diminish its extent.

As in the Caribbean, when smallpox struck, it was a consequence of European economic pursuits.

Yes, Native Americans Were the Victims of Genocide

An arithmetic approach assigning the majority of total deaths to disease would argue against regarding the last phase in depopulation as genocide, yet why should the number of Indians in that region who had died earlier from disease have any bearing on an assessment of whether the annihilation of the survivors would qualify as genocide or not?

The role of the federal government is more complicated. Though most of the Red Sticks killed were combatants, between two and three hundred were shot down while trying to escape by swimming across the Tallapoosa River. By the time Christopher Columbus reached the Caribbean inhistorians estimate that there were 10 million indigenous peoples living in U.

Like other Indians in similar circumstances, Seminoles were often able to evade U. The first Native American group encountered by Columbus, theArawaks of Haiti, were enslaved.

Genocides in history

For the most part, though, Indians were unwilling to risk massive casualties they were especially concerned to protect women and children and so generally evacuated their towns, knowing they would be torched.

Under a strict definition requiring a federal or state government intention to kill all California Indians and an outcome in which the majority of deaths were from direct killing, genocide does not seem applicable.

In a sense, I agree with the sentiment, but only in this: Direct killing was a significant factor and may have explained the majority of deaths for some nations, such as the Yukis and Yanas, but overall more people died from disease and malnutrition as they were subjected to coerced labor, land loss, destruction of game, and reservation confinement.

Genocide and American Indian History

Between andUS citizens kidnapped 4, Indian children from these groups in California. Reservations were established in the midth century, and the conditions there were so brutal, Adolf Hitler is said to have used them in part as a blueprint for his Final Solution. Controversy has surrounded cases where state officials forcibly removed children from Native American families.

The actions of the Pilgrims and Puritans toward Indians, especially, are seen as constitutive and emblematic of a subsequent colonial and U. A reported forty-three Potawatomis in a group of eight hundred died as they traveled from Indiana to Kansas, while sixty Wyandots, mostly young children, in a group of seven hundred died from disease shortly after their arrival in the West.

The quest for personal possessions was to be, from the outset, a series of raids, irresponsible and criminal, a spree, in which an end to it — the slaves, the timber, the pearls, the fur, the precious ores, and, later, arable land, coal, oil, and iron ore — was never visible, in which an end to it had no meaning.

Today historians, anthropologists and archaeologists are revealing that information on this holocaust is being deliberately eliminated from the knowledge base and consciousness of North Americans and the world.

But in actuality, this land had already been discovered — millions of Natives had occupied the Western Hemisphere for hundreds of years. The former slave owner could not believe the sheer barbarism he witnessed: Or what if they attacked or raided settlers who trespassed on their land and damaged its resources?

For Lemkin, genocide was broadly defined and included all attempts to destroy a specific ethnic group, whether strictly physical through mass killings, or cultural or psychological through oppression and destruction of indigenous ways of life.

An analysis of genocide as the extermination of native americans

University of Oklahoma Press, Raphael Lemkinthe originator of the term "genocide", considered the colonial replacement of Native Americans by English and later British colonists to be one of the historical examples of genocide.

One argument is that genocide does not apply since disease was the primary factor in the depopulation of California Indians; another is that mass violence was undertaken primarily by settlers and that the state and federal governments did not establish a policy of physically killing all Indians.

During the removal process in the s, approximately 2, Choctaws, 4, Creeks, and 5, Cherokees perished, mostly from intersecting factors of disease, starvation, exposure, and demoralization. The Indian Wars Any discussion of genocide must, of course, eventually consider the so-called Indian Wars, the term commonly used for U.

So this is the system that was unleashed in the so-called "New World.This paper, written under the title, “U.S. Settler-Colonialism and Genocide Policies,” was delivered at the Organization of American Historians Annual Meeting in St. Louis, MO on April 18, California's Native population experienced colossal devastation as white working men and their families immigrated to the Pacific Northwest.Indigenous Americans lived in California midth century (The Great California Genocide (Daily Kos)).

Were American Indians the Victims of Genocide?

But this would change. Related Link Yes, Native Americans Were the Victims of Genocide By Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz. On September 21, the National Museum of the American Indian will open its doors.

In an interview early this. As such, they have tried to appropriate the tragic extermination of Native Americans as representative of their own state of affairs. The facts simply do not matter when the extermination of the Jews is the goal.

Genocide and American Indian History

Dinesh D'Souza, a John M. National liberation, national renaissance, the restoration of nationhood to the an analysis of the portrayal of ancient rulers throughout history people, commonwealth: whatever may be an analysis of genocide as the extermination of native americans the headings used or the an analysis of harrison bergeron by kurt vonnegut new formulas introduced.

Numerous atrocities against Native Americans span the hundreds of years from the first arrival of European explorers to the modern era under a wide range of circumstances. Today there are over Native American tribes in the United States, each with a distinct culture, way of life and history.

An analysis of genocide as the extermination of native americans
Rated 4/5 based on 28 review